Saturday, May 19, 2012

"Effect of exercise on perceived stress"?

I have been exercising regularly (several times a week, at least a half hour of cardio and about 45 minutes of horizontal exercise, abs etc.) for about 6 months now. 
Yeah, I lost some weight. Yeah, my size shrank. A lot actually. No, I'll never be athletic. I'll never "look" thin or fit or muscular. But I do have to say, I feel way better. Waaaaaaaaaaay better. Shocking, I know... 


Not physically. I do not feel better physically. I never felt bad in the first place, physically. I always felt fine physically, even when I weighed 50 pounds more than I do now. 


I don't feel stronger, or more coordinated, or more powerful, or that I have more endurance for life. Yes, I can last longer on a treadmill or whatever (as long as there is a TV set in front of it), but not for regular life.  


I can't really do more stuff.. What I can do, now, though, is stew less about the stuff that there is to do. I have different feelings about the mess that is life. 


My attitude is better. I am more dispassionate about dealing with what needs to be done. I feel less helpless in the face of it all. I feel less despondent about how, realistically, none of it probably matters now, or will in the future. Not even a pick. After I die I will be gone, that's all there is to it. No lasting dint on the world. And that's all fine by me, on every level of myself. On as many levels as I can currently perceive, at least. 


All that matters is what's right in front of my nose, to be done either Right Now, or Soon. Until my long range plans show up inside that front-of-the-nose zone, I don't care. Not anymore. 


I've lowered the pressure I put on myself somehow. For now at least. I don't gaze around at the rest of my life, a landscape littered with "Stuff that Must be Taken Care of Before the Final Croak" and worry over what course to plot to get as much done as I can. I seem to have just started to move out in any old random direction, and do whatever there is right in front of me, there. Which opens a path to the next Thing That Must be Done. Then the next after that. I'm letting the path emerge of its own accord instead of feeling I must be solely responsible for planning, controlling, and executing it. I don't care. Whatever happens will happen. It will all be fine. Nothing really matters anyway. 
(It would be nice if this turned itself into "don't worry, be happy", but I'm fine if that never happens. Just getting from where I was to here feels like progress. I know I can't have it All, and I've always been OK with that.) 


Some internal friction that used to annoy the bejeebers out of me, though, seems to have simply...  disappeared. Moving more, is now/has become, a mental and emotional habit, not just a physical habit. Exercise helped me move off the 'mood' square I used to be stuck on. 


I googled "effect of exercise on perceived stress" and for 2012 alone there are 28,900 papers in google scholar. One would have to weed carefully, of course, and toss out all papers that did not specifically link exercise specifically to reduction of specific "perceived" stress - this is what a true-blue scholar would have to do, which I do not pretend to be, as I'm not trying to earn a PhD or anything..  still, there is a whole ball park to be explored, just for fun maybe. Maybe in some other lifetime. 


TEDxBayArea - KellyMcGonigal - The Science of Willpower



Monday, May 14, 2012

"Know Your Neurons: The Discovery and Naming of the Neuron" (SciAm)


LINK----> Know Your Neurons: The Discovery and Naming of the Neuron


This caught my eye today, by Ferris Jabr ( @ferrisjabr ). 

The third paragraph:
"Only recently, however, have I begun to recognize and appreciate the extraordinary diversity of cells in the nervous system—cells that differ from one another more than the cells of any other organ. Some neurons send electrical signals along fibers that stretch several feet; other neurons’ branches extend only a few millimeters away from the cell body. Some neurons possess a fractal beauty similar to that of ferns and corals: Purkinje cells, for example, often sport finely branched nets, like a sea fan. But some of their neighbors look more like tangled tumbleweeds. One neuron might appear more or less round under the microscope—like a firework frozen in climax—whereas another might spider through the brain like a daddy longlegs. Neurons not only differ in shape—different types of neurons turn on different sets of genes and not all neurons use the same chemicals to communicate. Excitatory neurons mostly stimulate other cells; inhibitory neurons prefer to stifle. Most neurons fire in patterns, but their tempos vary: some keep a steady beat, others remain largely silent except for the occasional burst of activity and still other cells continually fire like a trigger-happy toddler playing laser tag. To summarize: not all neurons are exactly alike. The brain contains multitudes."

I think that paragraph is just beautiful.  



Sunday, May 13, 2012

Book review: "The Graded Motor Imagery Handbook"

With the release of The Graded Motor Imagery Handbook this spring, Noigroup (Neuro Orthopaedic Institute) takes itself, and by extension, the physiotherapy profession, out of “tissues”, past the foramen magnum, and into the brain, which provides (at least to this PT reviewer) a bridge across the Cartesian chasm that long ago divided the branch of the profession which considers itself “Neuro”, from the one that considers itself “Ortho”; this bridge is built from fifteen years of deep Noigroup marination in neuro and pain science and education.

It’s a team effort, coauthored by G. Lorimer Moseley, David S. Butler, Timothy B. Beames, and Thomas J Giles; it manages to deliver complex material with whimsy and friendliness. The book’s size, shape, font, flat spiral binding, colourful chapter and page layout, and artwork, engage the reader, and make the content seem much less daunting to study and learn. In a mere 143 pages, The GMI Handbook ambitiously (and successfully) tackles multiply-leveled objectives:

1. Introduce and explain the entire topic to clinicians and patients;
2. Explain why the topic deserves attention, understanding, and implementation by clinicians and patients;
3. Provide a conceptual trail;
4. Provide products, services and support to clinicians and patients to implement the program.

We are given an introductory tour of the book by Butler, who, as an adult educator as well as a longtime PT, speaking to both practitioners and patients, admits this is new territory for PT; although the navigating map may still lack fine detail, he is confident that clinical reasoning should suffice to keep us on track, and his enthusiasm for exploring and charting this new frontier is contagious.

Patients who have persistent, non-medical pain, he explains, need to “exercise their synapses,” lubricate them with knowledge, first; then, subsequently, moving their physicality may feel easier. All behaviours occur within a given context, defined as “the temporary environment of an action or planned action”:

“Knowledge is a very special context. It can be de-threatening, give meaning to your symptoms, provide explanations, help with compliance, allow problem-solving, link to future goals, allow progression of treatment and it can be passed on to other people like a useful virus.” - [p. 7]
Knowledge can be superficial or deep; a new idea will challenge many old ideas, may jostle them aside somewhat. A learner (such as a person with persistent pain) who is prepared for this, will be able to entertain options for moving old beliefs aside, permit new information to enter safely and deeply into his or her own brain, so that it can help change the overall synaptic structure of the brain itself - the ultimate goal is to provide one’s brain with new options based on new information, so that it may eventually change its pain production and pain perception.

The second chapter by Moseley lays out the map of this new territory in as much detail as the book allows for. He recounts his personal journey toward this frontier, reading Ramachandran, meeting Butler, becoming interested in mirror therapy. He explains ‘neurotags’, defines them as, “a network of interconnected neurons..distributed throughout the brain. When a neurotag is activated it produces an output. The output defines the neurotag” [- p 24].

The neurotag is not the bread you smell: it does not produce the odour itself, does not detect it. The neurotag is not the neck pain you feel: it does not produce the neck pain, nor does it detect it. The neurotag is the experience of smelling the bread, the experience of feeling the neck pain. In other words, it is not primary sensation - it’s a kind of “learning” that has occurred by natural synaptic connection. A neurotag will activate when a threshold is reached, and when its member brain cells fire in concert, with no non-member cells firing at the same time. A ‘sensitized’ neurotag for experiencing pain is conceptualized as one whose activation threshold is too low, and whose nearby non-member neurons are too inactive, and therefore don’t or can’t contribute to inhibition.
For most people with pain, actual movement hurts. Without practice, parts of the brain that produce movement have become underused, and their synaptic strength has started to degrade. Primate brains are visually dominant. Humans are primates. Therefore, visual systems are recruited to assist - hence the term, graded motor imagery.

“Explicit” graded motor imagery is imagining yourself moving a body part. In the third chapter by Tim Beames, it is defined as a “process in which you are aware of yourself thinking about what you are doing” [-p. 79]. Through careful data collection, the researchers found out that this could still activate pain neurotags in some people (ouch, not good.) This means, for some people, even just imagining a movement can make their pain feel worse.

So the researchers proposed, and found, a way to get around that: “IMPLICIT” graded motor imagery is a delightfully sneaky process whereby movement-producing parts of the brain can be helped to rehabilitate, their neurons can be excited, but without activating any “pain” neurotags in the process!

The first stage is to help the brain relearn how to make left and right judgements about body physicality, both position of part itself, and various positions of various parts in space. Implicit motor imagery, or right/left judgment, activates pre-motor areas of the brain, which can then excite motor cells, but doesn’t directly activate them. The hypothesis is, that exposure to and engagement with implicit motor imagery can thereby sneak some learning in under the sensory-motor radar, so to speak, help the brain build the synaptic strength needed to undermine, inhibit and dampen the pain neurotag, because it can secondarily excite the motor area without activating either it or its connected pain neurotag! The brain will gradually and naturally tilt toward greater efficiency of inhibition, especially if it thinks changing is its own idea, that the change is coming from within instead of from without.

All of this sheds fascinating light on the “locus of control” aspect of brain function. It is a clever set-up indeed that can move locus of control around, and back and forth, right inside a brain!

Moseley has taken Melzack’s neuromatrix model of body-self a step further in his work, introducing the idea of a cortical body matrix, which integrates not just maps of the body, but also its surveillance, proprioception, regulation and protection, and not only the body - but also its surrounding space as well! The ‘cortical body matrix’ comprises a ‘network of networks’ - it includes “the suite of body systems that can be disrupted in a range of neurological and psychiatric conditions, including chronic pathological pain” [- p. 35].  He says that bias away from the “painful” side of the body includes a bias away from the space occupied by that part, as well; i.e., the brain prioritizes ‘away’ from the “painful” space. Delayed response time judging one side compared to the other led to this idea. Why the brain does this is as yet unknown; Moseley suspects the brain’s body-space maps may be disrupted somehow, although he isn’t fully committed to that idea quite yet.

Patients who embark on a course of implicit motor imagery training are counselled to enjoy the journey, not rush toward the destination - they are asked to develop and engage patience, persistence, courage and commitment. Possible pitfalls and obstacles are mentioned in the book, plausible explanations put forward.

The main tools for implicit motor imagery training are sets of cards depicting body regions and parts in various positions. The term “vanilla image” appears without warning on p. 45, without definition. (One must wait until chapter 5, p. 134, to learn from Tom Giles that “vanilla” refers to a “basic” image, on plain coloured background, without context, but one in which the body part has been randomly rotated 90, 180, and 270 degrees.) The patient is started with “basic” (unrotated, plain background) images, then “vanilla” images, and eventually moves to images of body parts inside a given context, i.e., how they might appear in magazines etc. The task is to decide as fast as possible, based on a quick glance only, if one is looking at a right or left side, or hand, or foot, etc. Scores improve over time as the brain’s synapses find each other after repeated exposure, and start to hook up. 



Figure 3.1 Flowchart showing ideal sequential progression of the different elements of graded motor imagery (GMI). From p. 61, The Graded Motor Imagery Handbook 


The third chapter by Tim Beames is a “nuts&bolts” description of the implementation of the program, outlining several how-tos, and what-ifs. Explicit motor imagery is a way of practicing a motor skill or activity which engages the brain parts involved, including the motor cortex, but without actually physically performing the motor actions - exercising the “virtual” body but not the physical one. The inner regulation control systems don’t really know the difference though - heart rate may respond to the imagined movement by increasing, for example. Patients graduate to this, and to mirror therapy, which involves the actual motor cortex to produce real movement, once they have successfully navigated implicit motor imagery, and have improved their right-left judgement scores. Graded exposure and pacing tips are woven throughout. Case studies are described. The goal is not just pain relief - the goal is to help the patient’s brain regain flexibility and creativity!

Butler returns in Chapter 4 to discuss stories, images and metaphors that can help move the process along.

In Chapter 5, Tom Giles explains how to set up a “Recognize” program on the computer or as a mobile app., essential aid to clinicians who want to integrate this whole system into a busy practice, or to patients who need to access it any time of the day or night.

I think prior exposure to neuroanatomy would be helpful, so I am including in this review an image I like very much from Mayo Clinic Medical Neurosciences 5th edition, depicting how inputs funnel themselves within the brain, from afferent sensory systems to output systems, premotor, and motor cortex. 

Fig. 16B.11 Hierarchical processing of information in cerebral cortex. From p. 713, Mayo Clinic Medical Neurosciences, 5th Ed. (2008) Benarroch EE et al., Informa Healthcare 

I would have appreciated having “vanilla image” explained earlier in the The GMI Handbook, or appear in the index, but I can also understand how individuals in a group, working feverishly on a project, may understand perfectly well what each other means and completely overlook the fact that no one outside the group may know what they mean by a certain word. (That is really my only negative criticism, and it’s a pretty small one!)


Overall this book is a pleasure to look at, handle, read, and use. It represents expansion of the profession beyond its ordinary knowledge base, providing hope to all clinicians who may be dissatisfied with the tools we were taught based on information that is no longer relevant, and to patients who want their practitioners to learn something new that might help them recover their own neural and movement capacities, and hopefully help their brains unlearn pain!








Thursday, May 10, 2012

Changing PT

After 40 years in this profession, it is ever clearer to me that at the individual level one has to become the change one wants to see in the world. 


I like this article I saw posted to Facebook today, Good to Great by Jim Collins. It talks about companies, but I think certain aspects apply just as well to professions. 


My two favorite excerpts (bolds and strikeouts and adds mine).


1. First, development:  
"Picture an egg. Day after day, it sits there. No one pays attention to it. No one notices it. Certainly no one takes a picture of it or puts it on the cover of a celebrity-focused business magazine. Then one day, the shell cracks and out jumps a chicken. 
All of a sudden, the major magazines and newspapers jump on the story: “Stunning Turnaround at Egg!” and “The Chick Who Led the Breakthrough at Egg!” From the outside, the story always reads like an overnight sensation—as if the egg had suddenly and radically altered itself into a chicken. 
Now picture the egg from the chicken's point of view. 
While the outside world was ignoring this seemingly dormant egg, the chicken within was evolving, growing, developing—changing. From the chicken’s point of view, the moment of breakthrough, of cracking the egg, was simply one more step in a long chain of steps that had led to that moment. Granted, it was a big step—but it was hardly the radical transformation that it looked like from the outside. 
It’s a silly analogy, but then our conventional way of looking at change is no less silly. Everyone looks for the “miracle moment” when “change happens.” But ask the good-to-great executives change agents when change happened. They cannot pinpoint a single key event that exemplified their successful transition."


2. Second, flywheel effect: 
"..picture a huge, heavy flywheel. It’s a massive, metal disk mounted horizontally on an axle. It's about 100 feet in diameter, 10 feet thick, and it weighs about 25 tons. That flywheel is your company. Your job is to get that flywheel to move as fast as possible, because momentum—mass times velocity—is what will generate superior economic results over time. 
Right now, the flywheel is at a standstill. To get it moving, you make a tremendous effort. You push with all your might, and finally you get the flywheel to inch forward. After two or three days of sustained effort, you get the flywheel to complete one entire turn. You keep pushing, and the flywheel begins to move a bit faster. It takes a lot of work, but at last the flywheel makes a second rotation. You keep pushing steadily. It makes three turns, four turns, five, six. With each turn, it moves faster, and then—at some point, you can’'t say exactly when—you break through. The momentum of the heavy wheel kicks in your favor. It spins faster and faster, with its own weight propelling it. You aren't pushing any harder, but the flywheel is accelerating, its momentum building, its speed increasing. 
This is the Flywheel Effect. It's what it feels like when you’re inside a company profession that makes the transition from good to great. Take Kroger, for example. How do you get a company profession with more than 50,000 hundreds of thousands of people to embrace a new strategy that will eventually change every aspect of every grocery store patient encounter? You don’t. At least not with one big change program. 
Instead, you put your shoulder to the flywheel. That’s what Jim Herring, the leader who initiated the transformation of Kroger, told us. He stayed away from change programs and motivational stunts. He and his team began You begin turning the flywheel gradually, consistently—building tangible evidence that their plans made new frame around the profession makes sense and would can deliver results."



Tuesday, April 24, 2012

Treatment continuum III




9. Locus of control:



On the left side of the diagram, when peoples' bodies develop a frank disease or trauma, operators step in, save life, save limb, or at least try to. The operator assumes the locus of control.

On the right side of the diagram, when people develop non-life threatening conditions, or are recovering from them, or strive to prevent ill health in the first place, helpers interact with people to assist their learning. People retain their own locus of control; the helpers are viewed more as consultants or advisors.



10: The underlying perspective:




On the left, a Cartesian perspective is assumed; namely, body is viewed as something completely separable from the "mind".  A third party can intervene, ignore the "mind", deal with the "body", then drop back, and magically the patient's mind and body will return to seamless continuity. This is true, certainly, if loss of consciousness is present.

On the right,  a patient's conscious mind/cognizing function is assumed to be intact at all times and part of the entire process. Nothing can happen, really, without the involvement and cooperation of the fully awake and cognizing person receiving the help from the helper. The basic perspective adopted is known as biopsychosocial. No loss of consciousness is involved. In fact, everything hinges on the recipient's attention span, ability to focus, learn, and change his or her own behaviour.


11. Types of operator interventions:



Here we can see types of interventions that could be seen as true operator interventions, i.e., the list with "medical" at the top. In this list, most of the procedures require some sort of anesthesia.

The second list is in the operator side of the picture because the "operators" performing the function have learned to do their work (inappropriately) from a bottom up Cartesian perspective. There is no anesthesia required or dispensed. These approaches could be characterized as coercive, although the operators have the option of learning how to perform them in a more interactive fashion.

The "operators" in this list imagine
1. that they have locus of control,
2. that they are affecting the patient from the outside, the body, in.

In my opinion, they are deluding themselves, and their patients, simply by the way they were taught to think (inadvertently), or else deliberately.  In any case, they (mostly) do not consider the nervous system in their reasoning, nor do they imagine their treatment to have any direct effect on it, or that it might produce different output based on novel input; rather they tend to assume that the work they do on their tissue of choice eventually has been registered positively by the patient's passive nervous system. They allow themselves to imagine they have accomplished something outside the organism's control, and take full credit for getting the job done right.


12. Types of interactor interventions:




This includes anything anyone does to anyone which involves acknowledgement of the awareness and conscious veto power of the human nervous system, from its most peripheral, to its innermost central aspects. It includes a broad spectrum from the most committed one-to-one physical contact, to hands-off group work, to social programs designed to benefit the entire troop from top to bottom and over time.

To the left we see massage, right at the border between mesoderm and ectoderm, focusing on "muscle" but also on treatment dyad dynamics.
Beside it we see neurodynamics. This is a recently evolved treatment method whereby nerves are slid about through limbs and spines. It evolved out of "ortho", still retains a focus on "tissue", but the main focus is now on pain as an output, so it has moved further to the right, into the domain of ectodermal, of biopsychosocial.
Just to the right of that, we see DNM. This is my baby. It stands for dermoneuromodulation. It also evolved toward the right, and away from operator methods and massage. Focus is on cutaneous nerves, pain as a biopsychosocial brain output. It assumes that non-nociceptive novel input will result in altered (usually less) pain output.
To the right of it, we see SC. SC stands for simple contact, Barrett Dorko's baby. It deals with the peripheral nerves and nervous system as well, but leans a bit more toward different movement output based on novel input.
Beside its right, we see a whole host of exercise schools of thought. Exercise can do wonders for practically anything.
Moving further to the right, we have several examples of purely interactive strategies at group, societal and individual levels.

13. Putting it all together:



Here is the whole thing, finally. It's a busy slide, may need tinkering, but most of it is accounted for I think.


TREATMENT CONTINUUM I
TREATMENT CONTINUUM II

Treatment continuum II

6. Pattern recognition and explanation:



PATTERNICITY, ABSTRACTION, CONCEPTUALIZATION, APOPHENIA:
Because we are human, we do mental activity known as abstraction and conceptualization. We can't help ourselves. Things just turned out that way. Our brains evolved to recognize patterns, even false ones, and build conceptual baskets in which to store them, and from where we can retrieve them later, or compare  them to new patterns we see in the moment. It also evolved to believe that conceptualizations and abstractions, symbols for real things, are just as real as the things they symbolize.
The brain is a zoom lens. It distorts everything, including knowledge. So, science developed in order to correct for that. It's a way of smoothing out distortion of individuals by comparing more knowledge and more conceptual baskets than a single human brain ever could, using mathematical and statistical tools that have been agreed, collectively, do the job, if not to complete perfection, at least a whole lot more objectively than just one person's opinion. This clears away a lot of conceptual clutter.

EVIDENCE-BASED:
"Evidence-based" means that someone scientifically quantified the results from a bunch of interventions, and was able to show there was a "statistically significant" result, a positive treatment effect, that lasted over a given period of time. If it did this in the past, it is likely to be able to do this into the future, over time, become "predictable" which increases confidence in the method.

MECHANISM:
Evidence-based does not explain mechanism however. Other kinds of science (also relying on quantifiability) delve into mechanism and ultimately, converge to produce the world of thought's Best Guess as to What Might be Going on.


7. That which lies outside scientific scrutiny:




Here we see arrows on each side pointing to what is outside the range of evidence-based treatment.

In my mind (with all its individual bias) I see what is to the left, as being body-targeted interventions or conceptualizations, based on premises which have been disproven over time.

On the right, the bulge sticking outside the border of science represents human pursuits mostly uninteresting to or inaccessible by science (although science has made inroads there anyway).


8. Below are what, in my own mind, belong in these two groups of items.



This leaves us with that big empty area in the middle to fill up. Which is where we are going next.


TREATMENT CONTINUUM I
TREATMENT CONTINUUM III

















Treatment continuum I

Rather than write write write to describe how I view the treatment spectrum, I have made a bunch of pictures illustrating how I have come to view the archeology of it over time.


1. We start with a simple diagram of a human organism:
Every human organism starts out as a single cell, which becomes a two-layered blob, ectoderm on top and endoderm on the bottom. Ectoderm builds the nervous system.

Ectoderm gives off some cells which leak down under it, between the two layers, called mesoderm.


2. Mesoderm builds the structural parts of the body.


3. When we put them together we get this:





The peripheral nervous system is where the two overlap.
So, very simple, very schematically, this is what we treat.
The patient is alive, conscious, his or her brain straining to understand what it must do to cooperate.
We provide said brain with some good pain education, before we "do" anything else.

4. Here is a simple diagram to represent all interventions anyone makes for anyone. It's expandable.




5. When laid over top of the human organism we end up with something like this:



The larger circle in front represents that which can be scientifically studied, and evidence obtained.

OPERATOR MODELS:
"Operator model interventions", on the left, target the "body". These are generally "practitioner knows best" types of interventions. The patient may be informed but the treatment plan is well-worn and not particularly subject to debate.

INTERACTOR MODELS:
On the right, we see "Interactor model interventions" which include the patient him or herself,  the patient's conscious awareness, seek to obtain permission and cooperation, active participation. The patient is taught that they retain full locus of control, and how to use it. They are encouraged to provide feedback and think of possible alterations to the plan themselves. Together the practitioner and the patient map out a path together, over time.

For more about these two ways of thinking about treating patients, see this google document on the topic. 
The line of demarcation between the two isn't usually as clear as it appears in the picture.

More to come.

TREATMENT CONTINUUM II
TREATMENT CONTINUUM III
Operator/Interactor models (google doc)



Saturday, April 07, 2012

Pain and tissue damage are from different planets.

Kory Zimney at SomaSimple found and collected together a bunch of papers showing the complete lack of predictable correlation between "tissue damage" and pain, in the neck, shoulder and low back. Many of them are open access, so I thought I'd collect them here, too. 


1. Magnetic Resonance Imaging of the Lumbar Spine in People Without Back Pain. 


AbstractBACKGROUND:The relation between abnormalities in the lumbar spine and low back pain is controversial. We examined the prevalence of abnormal findings on magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) scans of the lumbar spine in people without back pain.METHODS:We performed MRI examinations on 98 asymptomatic people. The scans were read independently by two neuroradiologists who did not know the clinical status of the subjects. To reduce the possibility of bias in interpreting the studies, abnormal MRI scans from 27 people with back pain were mixed randomly with the scans from the asymptomatic people. We used the following standardized terms to classify the five intervertebral disks in the lumbosacral spine: normal, bulge (circumferential symmetric extension of the disk beyond the interspace), protrusion (focal or asymmetric extension of the disk beyond the interspace), and extrusion (more extreme extension of the disk beyond the interspace). Nonintervertebral disk abnormalities, such as facet arthropathy, were also documented.RESULTS:Thirty-six percent of the 98 asymptomatic subjects had normal disks at all levels. With the results of the two readings averaged, 52 percent of the subjects had a bulge at at least one level, 27 percent had a protrusion, and 1 percent had an extrusion. Thirty-eight percent had an abnormality of more than one intervertebral disk. The prevalence of bulges, but not of protrusions, increased with age. The most common nonintervertebral disk abnormalities were Schmorl's nodes (herniation of the disk into the vertebral-body end plate), found in 19 percent of the subjects; annular defects (disruption of the outer fibrous ring of the disk), in 14 percent; and facet arthropathy (degenerative disease of the posterior articular processes of the vertebrae), in 8 percent. The findings were similar in men and women.CONCLUSIONS:On MRI examination of the lumbar spine, many people without back pain have disk bulges or protrusions but not extrusions. Given the high prevalence of these findings and of back pain, the discovery by MRI of bulges or protrusions in people with low back pain may frequently be coincidental.
(What?? Over HALF of all these asymptomatic, no pain, no complaints, people, have a disc bulge??)


2. Abnormal magnetic-resonance scans of the lumbar spine in asymptomatic subjects. A prospective investigation


We performed magnetic resonance imaging on sixty-seven individuals who had never had low-back pain, sciatica, or neurogenic claudication. The scans were interpreted independently by three neuro-radiologists who had no knowledge about the presence or absence of clinical symptoms in the subjects. About one-third of the subjects were found to have a substantial abnormality. Of those who were less than sixty years old, 20 per cent had a herniated nucleus pulposus and one had spinal stenosis. In the group that was sixty years old or older, the findings were abnormal on about 57 per cent of the scans: 36 per cent of the subjects had a herniated nucleus pulposus and 21 per cent had spinal stenosis. There was degeneration or bulging of a disc at at least one lumbar level in 35 per cent of the subjects between twenty and thirty-nine years old and in all but one of the sixty to eighty-year-old subjects. In view of these findings in asymptomatic subjects, we concluded that abnormalities on magnetic resonance images must be strictly correlated with age and any clinical signs and symptoms before operative treatment is contemplated.


(You mean, like a third ... of ordinary people walking around without any pain, have a verifiably trashed back?)  


3. MRI Findings in Throwing Shoulders




Shoulders of throwing athletes are highly stressed joints and likely to have more structural abnormalities seen on magnetic resonance imaging scans. Prevalence and type of structural abnormalities, especially abnormalities of the rotator cuff tendons and the superolateral humeral head, and correlation of magnetic resonance imaging findings with symptoms and clinical tests, are not well known. Throwing and nonthrowing (symptomatic and asymptomatic) shoulders of 30 fully competitive professional handball players and 20 dominant shoulders of randomly selected volunteers were evaluated for comparison clinically and with magnetic resonance imaging. An average of seven abnormal magnetic resonance imaging findings was observed in the throwing shoulders; more than in the nonthrowing and the control shoulders. Although 93% of the throwing shoulders had abnormal magnetic resonance imaging findings, only 37% were symptomatic. Partial rotator cuff tears and mainly superolateral osteochondral defects of the humeral head were identified as typical throwing lesions. Symptoms correlated poorly with abnormalities seen on magnetic resonance imaging scans and findings from clinical tests. This suggests that the evaluation of an athlete’s throwing shoulder should be done very thoroughly and should not be based mainly on abnormalities seen on magnetic resonance imaging scans.


(Structural abnormalities don't go together with shoulder pain in pitchers? What? No correlation between tissue "damage" and pain?)


4. MRI of cervical intervertebral discs in asymptomatic subjects


We studied degenerative changes in the cervical intervertebral discs of 497 asymptomatic subjects by MRI and evaluated disc degeneration by loss of signal intensity, posterior and anterior disc protrusion, narrowing of the disc space and foraminal stenosis. In each subject, five disc levels from C2-C3 to C6-C7 were evaluated.
The frequency of all degenerative findings increased linearly with age. Disc degeneration was the most common observation, being present in 17% of discs of men and 12% of those of women in their twenties, and 86% and 89%  of discs of both men and women over 60 years of age. We found significant differences in frequency between genders for posterior disc protrusion and foraminal stenosis. The former, with demonstrable compression of the spinal cord, was observed in 7.6% of subjects, mostly over 50 years of age.
Our results should be taken into account when interpreting the MRI findings in patients with symptomatic disorders of the cervical spine.


(Even spinal cord compression? No symptoms? Wow. See? Asymptomatic people, bad images, pain and tissue damage have nothing to DO with each other!)




5. Natural history of lumbar disc hernia with radicular leg pain: Spontaneous MRI changes of the herniated mass and correlation with clinical outcome


A prospective sequential MRI study was done to investigate the morphologic changes of the lumbar disc hernia(LDH). We also studied the relationship between the MRI changes and the type of LDH and the clinical outcome. MRI was performed every 3 months from the onset for a maximum of 24 months in 42 patients with radicular leg pain and symptoms definitely diagnosed as caused by LDH. The size of the herniated mass was determined by the ratio of the anteroposterior diameter of the spinal canal to the maximum diameter of the LDH mass on T2-weighted axial images.
The clinical outcome was evaluated as excellent, good, or poor depending on leg pain and physical findings. The JOA (Japanese Orthopaedic Association) score for LDH was also used to assess the outcome.
Thirty-seven (88%) of the 42 patients showed >50% reduction of the hernia on MRI 3–12 months after onset, and the morphologic changes of the herniated mass were well correlated with the clinical outcome.


(Seriously? These things go away all by themselves? What?? Get out of town!)



















Thursday, April 05, 2012

At laaaaaaaaast....

"At laaaaaaaast.... my table's come along......"

Sorry Etta James, couldn't resist. The feeling is exactly right. (Minus the kinesthetic display in the video, apart from its symbolic beauty, I mean.)

Yup. Monday at 1:15 PM, the new table is to be delivered unto me.. or at least into the space I've been renting (hopefully, in anticipation) all winter. But not working in, because I did not have this beautiful table I expect with people upon, for the rest of my working days, being 61 and all.

I was in stasis mode. For months. Everything was completely out of my control, and all I could do was hang in there until things sorted themselves out.

Why? What was going on?
I arranged to rent working space, in advance of having adequate equipment, last October. When I had space secured, I ordered a treatment table. It was supposed to take ten weeks to be built in Belgium, imported, then moved to my little city in the prairies.

Well, it took longer than that, and I still don't know the whole story, because the guy in quebec who is the Canadian connection is very contained about all of it. Anyway, it was supposed to be here in January, but is now 2 and a half months overdue.

But today, the local moving company, here in my own town, called to arrange delivery. I learned the table weighs 302 pounds. That's a lot. But what I like is that it's a concrete detail, and concrete details reassure me.  That it exists. That it's here. That soon I'll be able to start using it.

The treatment room is in a spa, which is OK, because at least it smells good there.. My practice will have nothing to do with the spa business - it's just a room I'm renting there. I'll be my own business.

In November, December, I got the place furnished, in anticipation, with a name registered in the province, a phone (not yet connected, but with a number that I'm paying for every month), a desk, a partition dividing the space into treatment area and reception area, a file cabinet (a lateral three-drawer affair, which I hope will suffice to contain all the patient files I expect to accumulate for the rest of my life).

A lamp, because (alas!) the place does not have natural light, no window. (Which is if I'm really honest, a good chunk of the reason why I never moved in all winter even though I had procured a massage table - I couldn't bear to start up in a place with no window during the winter.)

So, in some ways, the timing worked out fine. I think I can stand working in there during summer, and I am negotiating with the landlady/spa-owner for a window to be installed, even just a light pipe would be a big help..

It HAS been nice, pretending to be retired - it gave me a great rest for almost 3 years, but the writing's on the wall; I've run out of surplus cash from having sold a paid-off condo in ridiculously expensive Vancouver. I've lost a pile of weight and gained a bunch of muscle. I'm ready to roam the world teaching, and maintain a completely relaxed practice to pay for groceries. Time to get busy I guess. And yes, I feel better. Not great, but better. Probably good enough. Bring it - I'm up for it.


Tuesday, April 03, 2012

Ah, now I remember.

I read a little thing this morning about Duchenne Muscular Dystrophy in this blogpost, and immediately recalled an event that happened while doing clinical training in PT school, over 40 years ago. We were still in school, but each morning we had to go to some assigned hospital to work with actual patients.

One of my patients one morning was a young boy, maybe 10 or 11 years old, with DMD. His lungs were full of sputum and he was too weak to cough effectively. His dad was there, sitting beside him. My job was to handle his chest wall to help support him to cough, and breathe. I'd been taught all sorts of fancy positions to supposedly aid in this effort, and got busy.

I really got into my task, and promptly lost track of time. The story of my life. I worked and worked and worked with him, and the kid expelled a great deal of sputum. Success. His dad sat by his side, watching hopefully, remaining contained, a silent and steady support. I was barely out of being a kid myself (18 at the time), and I was glad he was there.

After what seemed like five minutes had passed, but in reality had been almost an hour probably, another PT student came in, looking for me.
PT student: "Why didn't you answer your page?" 
Me: "What page? You were paging me? Why?" 
PT student: "You were supposed to be back in the department by 10 AM so we could all go to coffee together."  
Me: "Oh. Gee, sorry, I completely lost track of time, forgot, didn't hear the page. OK, I'll be there in a minute." 
PT student hurried off in order to enjoy her coffee and hang with the group.

This had been my first conscious experience of having immersed myself in free-falling interaction with another person's nervous system, then being rudely brought back to unwelcome social exigency, at the expense of the process that had begun to unfold and which I felt completely part of.  I remember that I felt confused and resentful, all mixed together. Sort of the story of my whole life, actually, now that I think about it. There has always been that kind of grind in my gears.

I took another look at the task: the kid was breathing much easier now, and I was fairly pleased with the job I had done. The dad was pleased too, and tried to reward me. He said, "I want you to have this pen." (He had quickly fished around for a present and had found it in his shirt.)

We had just had a big lecture in the department about how it was wrong to accept any gifts or money from patients, to gracefully refuse. So I tried to. It felt awkward and uncomfortable. Here was a guy genuinely trying to compensate me, as part of a completion of a therapeutic ritual which had been (at least temporarily) successful; he was genuinely grateful, and could probably see that I was struggling to unfold into a good therapist, wanted to mark his attendance at this event somehow, so, had been moved to do this, make this gesture. It wasn't just empty gesture. Even I could sense this, and I'm not really great at telling the difference. So, I tried, but in the end, I accepted his gift of his own 29 cent ballpoint pen, as a symbol of his own completion of a psychosocial moment, and expression of his own gratitude. I did not think I had any right to refuse, on that level. I mean, here was a guy watching his own son die slowly - I knew full well I'd never in a million years ever have the strength or grace to do anything like it. I was embarrassed about my robust health and good fortune in life. If he wanted me to have a dumb pen, then he had the right to bestow it, because he had earned that right.

I went to rejoin the human primate social grooming squad I had signed up to travel with through this phase of my life and training, but always kept an eye open for some way not to have to be subject to group dynamics and behaviour if I didn't want to, as it always has seemed mostly annoying and interruptive, as opposed to welcome and distracting. Looking back I can see now that all the discomfort I felt led me out of hospital work and toward working with pure pain in patients, and independently, as a solo practitioner, in order to be able to lose myself in the interactive process with no interruption.

Monday, March 12, 2012

Guest post at ForwardThinkingPT.com on Dermoneuromodulation

This is a copy of a guest post on dermoneuromodulation Joe Brence asked me to write for his blog, ForwardThinkingPT. com published earlier today. It contains the DNM roundup from yesterday.


I want to thank Joe for the opportunity to write a guest post for his blog about dermoneuromodulation. Even though I’ve been writing about it in one way or another for many years, it is hard to encapsulate this in under 1000 words and still be able to convey what I think needs to be conveyed. So, what I've done is present a brief outline, with a list of links at the end to blogposts, which discuss the topics in more detail, and which link to other posts for even more detail. 
HISTORY OF THE TERM: The term originated with a little bit of help from SomaSimple friends in the mid-2000’s as I struggled, as we all struggled, to become more conscious and articulate about manual therapy in general, and discuss problems inherent within it. David Butler’s neuromobilization workshop in the late 90’s, and discovering Melzack’s neuromatrix model of pain in 2003, plunged me into cognitive dissonance from which I have yet to emerge. In 2006 a colleague at the U. of Saskatchewan, and I, began a case series study (scheduled for write-up/ publication this year). Results indicated "weak but statistically significant" results, about what one would expect from a case series on any kind of manual treatment.
MEANING OF THE TERM: The word “dermoneuromodulation” simply means skin/nervous system/change. It does not imply that the practitioner is the one “doing” something called “change” “to” something anatomical in another person. It does not exclude the nervous system of the patient as change agent under its own auspices, thus DNM is as close to being an interactive model of manual care as opposed to an operator model as any kind of manual therapy approach can be, while still handling bodies of other (live, conscious) people. Other than “skin”, the surface all of us touch regardless of whatever else we might conjecture about what we are doing/affecting/handling, sensory endings, and cutaneous nerves, there is no mention of “tissue”. 
OPERATOR VERSUS INTERACTOR MODELS IN MANUAL TREATMENT: I have considered this quite closely, and all I want to say about it here is that I think, in the clinic, one should know when one is in one mode or the other, and be fluent in both. 
CONSIDERATIONS IMPORTANT TO SUCCESSFUL TREATMENT OF ANY KIND:
NERVOUS SYSTEM: Bearing in mind that we are treating live integral humans, conscious, awake, and usually presenting with pain , we have to (I think) consider their nervous system, and focus on creating a context that will favour their ability to change how they think and feel about their pain. We should share whatever information we may have about what “pain” is, how it behaves, with the patient, so we can both be on the same page. I wrote an extensive series of blog posts about developing the therapeutic container, called “New treatment encounter”. I present the nervous “system” as a signalling entity woven throughout the body, derived directly from the embryonic “builder”, ectoderm, continuous in a human adult from skin cell to sense of self. 
NEUROMATRIX MODEL: New Treatment encounter Part VI is specifically about the neuromatrix model, understanding it’s use for treatment, getting clear about our inputs (including manual therapy), and what we want to see happen with outputs. An elaboration of that can be found here. 
TUNNEL SYNDROMES: Pain experienced as persistent or recurrent and relatively localized (i.e., most mechanical “MSK” pain) is conceptualized as nerve pain.
NEURODYNAMICS: Peripheral nerves come all the way out to supply skin, sooner or later, proximally or distally, making them fairly easy to affect mechanically regardless of where or how one makes contact with skin. 
PERIPHERAL DISSEMINATION OF CUTANEOUS NERVES: A dissection of cutaneous rami done in 2007 revealed the macrostructure of cutaneous rami to the underside of skin. 
SKIN CONTACT: Skin is well supplied with exteroceptive receptors of all sorts and fibers that transmit information to the brain using fast dorsal column pathways and non-nociceptive slow spinothalamic pathways, to centers in both the internal regulation system and the primary sensory cortex of the brain. As long as the handling is mostly non-nociceptive, it will be physically safe for most pain presentations. A sensory ending known as the Ruffini ending is particularly capable of transducing lateral stretch to skin. It is slow adapting, which means it will actively fire the entire time a skin stretch is held, allowing the nervous system time and stimulation to alter its motor output and pain output at spinal cord and more rostral levels. 
IN SUMMARY: Research in manual therapy tells us that there is little or no interrater reliability for palpation or application, little or no agreement on what constitutes the overall best approach, and that success in terms of favourable outcomes depends a lot on context and treatment relationship. Applications differ widely in amount, intention, length, depth, angle, and zone of contact. I am of the opinion that manual therapy is optional, yet often may be optimal, to acheiving successful outcome in terms of pain reduction and movement improvement. The real trick in treatment is to leave the locus of control with the patient while still providing them with professional physical contact as required, by them, as individuals, in the moment, and within the context of a therapeutic relationship. I do not know what should be ruled out in order to show the world that manual therapy is useful; I only think that these items I’ve discussed should be left ruled in.
1. Dermoneuromodulation (diagram, gearing up)
2. Dermoneuromodulation: Where it came from
3. Dermoneuromodulation: Ruffini sensory endings and dorsolateral prefrontal cortex
4. Dermoneuromodulation: Neurodynamics, tunnel syndromes, cutaneous nerves.
5. Dermoneuromodulation: The neuromatrix model of pain
6. Dermoneuromodulation: Ascending pathways


Submitted by Diane Jacobs, March 11/2012

AFTERTHOUGHT: 7. Therapeutic Domain